Year of the Comet
Comet C/2011 L4 (PANSTARRS)

PANSTARRS information

Comet C/2012 S1 (ISON)

ISON information

Astronomy News
E-mail Article to a FriendPrint ArticleBookmark and Share

New IBEX data show heliosphere's long-theorized bow shock does not exist

The latest refinements in relative speed and local interstellar magnetic field strength prevent the “bubble” that surrounds our solar system from developing a bow shock.
By Southwest Research Institute, San Antonio, Texas Published: May 14, 2012
Bow-shock
The heliosphere is the region of space dominated by the Sun that cocoons Earth and the other planets. Inflated by the million-mile-per-hour solar wind, the bubble-shaped heliosphere pushes its way through the galaxy. For a quarter-century, researchers believed a bow "shock" formed ahead of the heliosphere as it moved through interstellar space — similar to the sonic boom made by a jet breaking the sound barrier. New data from NASA's Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX) shows that the heliosphere moves through space too slowly to form a bow shock. Courtesy Southwest Research Institute
New results from NASA's Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX) reveal that the bow shock, widely accepted by researchers to precede the heliosphere as it plows through tenuous gas and dust from the galaxy, does not exist.

The latest refinements in relative speed and local interstellar magnetic field strength prevent the heliosphere, the magnetic "bubble" that cocoons Earth and the other planets, from developing a bow shock. The bow shock would consist of ionized gas or plasma that abruptly and discontinuously changes in density in the region of space that lies straight ahead of the heliosphere.

"The sonic boom made by a jet breaking the sound barrier is an earthly example of a bow shock," said David McComas from the Southwest Research Institute (SwRI) in San Antonio, Texas. "As the jet reaches supersonic speeds, the air ahead of it can't get out of the way fast enough. Once the aircraft hits the speed of sound, the interaction changes instantaneously, resulting in a shock wave."

For about a quarter-century, researchers believed that the heliosphere moved through the interstellar medium at a speed fast enough to form a bow shock. IBEX data have shown that the heliosphere actually moves through the local interstellar cloud at about 52,000 mph (84,000 km/h), roughly 7,000 mph (11,000 km/h) slower than previously thought — slow enough to create more of a bow "wave" than a shock.

"While bow shocks certainly exist ahead of many other stars, we're finding that our Sun's interaction doesn't reach the critical threshold to form a shock, so a wave is a more accurate depiction of what's happening ahead of our heliosphere — much like the wave made by the bow of a boat as it glides through the water," said McComas.

Another influence is the magnetic pressure in the interstellar medium. IBEX data, as well as earlier Voyager observations, show that the magnetic field is stronger in the interstellar medium, requiring even faster speeds to produce a bow shock. Combined, both factors now point to the conclusion that a bow shock is highly unlikely.

The IBEX team combined its data with analytical calculations and modeling and simulations to determine the conditions necessary for creating a bow shock. Two independent global models — one from a group in Huntsville, Alabama, and another from Moscow — correlated with the analytical findings.

"It's too early to say exactly what this new data means for our heliosphere. Decades of research have explored scenarios that included a bow shock. That research now has to be redone using the latest data," said McComas. "Already, we know there are likely implications for how galactic cosmic rays propagate around and enter the solar system, which is relevant for human space travel."

IBEX's primary mission has been to image and map the invisible interactions occurring at the outer reaches of the solar system. Since its launch in October 2008, the spacecraft also has shed new light on the complex structure and dynamics occurring around Earth and discovered neutral atoms coming off the Moon.

Find us on FacebookFind us on Twitter
User Comments
Be the first to leave your comment below!

Only registered members of Astronomy.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes.

Register Today!
 
5 stars
STEPHEN ARMSTRONG from CALIFORNIA said:
Cool! Then the Voyagers are experiencing interstellar space as we speak. This would explain their anomalous velocities and bizarre instrument readings. If you were expecting a bow shock to be there, and it literally wasn't, you might misinterpret the data in bias of your predetermination. I suggest that the velocity anomaly stems from interstellar medium incursion effects, as it is a continuous effect. This would be expected if there were no actual "hard" boundary. The interstellar medium would simply achieve an equilibrium with Sol's wind. And probes that we send out probably wouldn't even experience the incursion effect until way past Neptune. (p.s. Has anyone determined when "the brakes" went on with the Voyager spacecraft's motions? Would that be pre or post Neptune?)
The probes' "indeterminate" readings (as of late) belie the fact that the hardware is experiencing, not the hard "bump" of a boundary, but the chaotic "transition" from local to macro magnetic fields regions. In contrast to a recent "Astronomy" magazine article, I do believe that within ten years, it will be clear to all that the Voyagers have been "between the stars".
5 stars
STEPHEN ARMSTRONG from CALIFORNIA said:
Pretty please; let's just stick to the subject at hand in the article.
5 stars
MIKE CAVEDON from MASSACHUSETTS said:
The Universe is, or the local Universe we exist in is in, a jet; analogous to the polar jet of a black hole.

Dark energy is aether emitted into the Universal jet.

It's not the Big Bang; it's the Big Ongoing.
4 stars
TED HUNT from MISSOURI said:
My own training is insufficient to critique the research, article or comments, but I am fascinated with the thought that older 'disproven' hypotheses can potentially inform and interpret current questions such as the nature of dark matter, dark energy, accelerated expansion, superstrings, compact dimensions, etc. It is in the interconnections of ideas that thought has its fullest flowering - today's theoretical dogma may find an altogether different synthesis in coming decades. What a ride!
5 stars
MIKE CAVEDON from MASSACHUSETTS said:
The Michelson-Morley experiment looked for an immobile aether the Earth moved through.

The aether is not immobile.

'Ether and the Theory of Relativity by Albert Einstein'
http://www-groups.dcs.st-and.ac.uk/~history/Extras/Einstein_ether.html

"the state of the [ether] is at every place determined by connections with the matter and the state of the ether in neighbouring places, ... disregarding the causes which condition its state."

The state of the aether at every place determined by connections with the matter and the state of the aether in neighboring places is the state of displacement of the aether.

The aether is, or behaves similar to, a superfluid with properties of a solid.

Aether has mass. Aether physically occupies three dimensional space. Aether is physically displaced by matter.

Displaced aether pushing back and exerting inward pressure toward matter is gravity.

A moving particle has an associated aether displacement wave. In a double slit experiment the particle has a well defined trajectory which takes it through one slit while the associated aether wave passes through both.
4 stars
ALAN L FALK from NORTH CAROLINA said:
ah, doesn't this really say that the density of the interstellar medium where the shock wave was expected is merely not dense enough for the solar system's velocity relative to it to be "supersonic"?
4 stars
KELLY FRAVEL from COLORADO said:
"Already, we know there are likely implications for how galactic cosmic rays propagate around and enter the solar system, which is relevant for human space travel."

Instead of reprinting an article... some means for Astronomy Mag. to answer obvious questions that are posed by another group... is needed.

Obviously there is an article here... does the above mean that cosmic rays are now a detriment to human space travel within the solar system or beyond it?

This also brings up... questions about the chaining idea of what is between stars and what ocean... each human, the Earth and our solar system swims in?

I am not technically train in this area... but I suspect that 'Dark Matter/ Dark Energy' are actually ideas only that humans at this point... are erecting around... a much more dense idea... a Something... that enfolds all physically expressed structure... and all 'information' and that too... in some ways our language and thought matrices... are still beguiling even our most gifted and trained minds.

Call me a dreamer... (proudly...) but if I were asked to define what are the great quests of humanity I would say: 1. To understand who we are verses the Vault of Heaven and 2. To transcend Light Speed's jail house.

In fact my own terribly romantic idea is that... because we are Raised Up by the Universe or call it Spirit if you will... into consciousness we are the eyes and the ears and the senses and the Mind... of something more... which too partakes in our wonder... is made whole by it... .

And, since... WE... not just our species... have dreamed of space travel and long for companionship... and understanding... we play our part in a great theater and its revelation... one result is the drive to "...seek out new life... " ... so it must be.
5 stars
KENNETH SMITH said:
I would not agree with Mike Cavedon's idea that this is the Aether in the sense that ancient scientists thought. The interstellar medium seems to be extremely tenuous in terms of interacting material. The very fact that the heliosphere travelling at 84,000 km/hr through the medium cannot create a bow shock, but only a wave, is indicative of just how tenuous it is. Not much would survive at that speed, without exploding, in even the thinnest parts of our atmosphere.
E ROBERT WARZESKI from LOUISIANA said:
OK, I'll bite. Didn't Michaelson & Morley prove that the Luminiferous Ether (or Aether to be more archaic) doesn't exist? While Michaelson didn't like the result, proving that the speed of light does not differ when measured parallel to and perpendicular to the Earth's motion around the sun showed that the Earth does not experience an "Ether wind" as it orbits the sun. This was interpreted by the Physics community as showing that there was no such thing. Any new evidence out there that I don't know about?
5 stars
MIKE CAVEDON from MASSACHUSETTS said:
'"While bow shocks certainly exist ahead of many other stars, we're finding that our Sun's interaction doesn't reach the critical threshold to form a shock, so a wave is a more accurate depiction of what's happening ahead of our heliosphere — much like the wave made by the bow of a boat as it glides through the water," said McComas.'

Aether has mass. Aether physically occupies three dimensional space. Aether is physically displaced by matter.

The wave ahead of our heliosphere is an aether displacement wave.
SEARCH SITE
Subscriber Only Access
Subscriber Only Content
Look for this icon. This denotes premium subscriber content. Learn more »
Become a Member of Astronomy.com
Register today for access to more valuable resource information.
Interact in our forums, comment on articles, receive our newsletter and much more!
Not a member?
Subscriber and Member Login
Password
Remember me