Tonight's Sky
Sun
Sun
Moon
Moon
Mercury
Mercury
Venus
Venus
Mars
Mars
Jupiter
Jupiter
Saturn
Saturn

Tonight's Sky — Change location

OR

Searching...

Tonight's Sky — Select location

Tonight's Sky — Enter coordinates

° '
° '

Who discovered Neptune?

In science, the terms “discovery” and “discoverer” can be loaded with controversy. And the story of Neptune serves as a prime example.
RELATED TOPICS: NEPTUNE | ASTRONOMY
Neptune
This image was compiled from the last images taken by Voyager 2's narrow angle camera.
NASA/JPL
Neptune is too faint to be seen with the naked eye. And when a famed observer first spotted it through his telescope, he didn’t realize what it was. However, that didn’t stop him from drawing it.

Between December 1612 and January 1613, Galileo Galilei sketched what he saw with his primitive telescope: a “point” near conjunction with Jupiter. Today, we know that “point” was exactly where Neptune was during those dates. It was just starting its retrograde — or backward — motion through the sky as seen from Earth. But Galileo seems to have mistook the planet for a star.
JustusSustermansPortraitofGalileoGalilei1636
Galileo Galilei may have been the first to spot the yet-to-be-discovered planet Neptune.
Justus Sustermans, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Fast-forward to 1821, and astronomers had identified a problem: The orbit of Uranus didn’t match up with their calculations. They concluded that an unknown world must be gravitationally disturbing the planet’s orbital path. The hunt to find it was on.

It took more than 20 years, however, before the young English astronomer and mathematician John Couch Adams started working on the problem. He had little confidence in his early results, which led him to keep starting over from scratch. But by early 1846, Adams had calculated new possible orbits for the predicted trans-Uranian planet. Still vacillating, though, he didn’t publish his work until November. Meanwhile, as Adams delayed releasing his results, French astronomer Urbain Le Verrier published his independent (and slightly different) calculations in June.
512pxUrbain_Le_Verrier

Urbain Le Verrier predicted the planet’s location and convinced astronomers to search for it.

User Magnus Manske on en.wikipedia, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Noticing the similarity between Le Verrier’s and Adams’ (still unpublished) results, British Astronomer Royal George Airey urged astronomer James Challis to immediately search the skies. Throughout August and September, Challis searched. But he didn’t look where Adams suggested. Instead, he looked at a much larger area of the sky, seeking targets fainter than what Adams predicted for the as-yet-undiscovered planet. Challis also didn’t take the time to note whether any objects moved from night to night. In other words, Challis’ search turned up nothing.

Meanwhile, after months of lukewarm responses from French astronomers, Le Verrier asked German astronomer Johann Galle to likewise hunt for the planet using Berlin Observatory’s telescope. Galle received Le Verrier’s letter on September 23, 1846. That same evening, Galle found Neptune. It was a mere 1 degree from Le Verrier’s predicted position, and 12 degrees from Adams’ prediction.

So, that raises the complicated question: Who really discovered Neptune? Adams? Le Verrier? Challis? Galle?

International controversy raged. Adams completed his calculations first, but Le Verrier published first. Le Verrier’s calculations were also more accurate. Challis did spot Neptune before Galle — twice. But out-of-date star maps and sloppy observing techniques meant he didn’t recognize it as a planet. International consensus eventually gave both Adams and Le Verrier joint credit.

And then, in 1999, a trove of long-lost (well, stolen) British documents came to light. They revealed a deliberate “bending of the facts” to make Adams’ role much stronger than it really was. While many sources still credit both men as the discoverers of Neptune, the historical evidence now says otherwise.

Credit for discovering Neptune must go to the person who predicted the planet’s location and convinced astronomers to search for it: Urbain Le Verrier.

But wait: In 2009 Australian physicist David Jamieson claimed Galileo did know he had spotted a planet, and that his notebooks prove it. In an entry on January 28, 1613 Galileo wrote that the “star” he saw appeared to have moved slightly relative to Jupiter. Jamieson also pointed to “a mysterious unlabeled black dot” in Galileo’s drawings for January 6. The black dot is in the correct position for Neptune. Jamieson hypothesized that Galileo added the dot to his earlier drawings “to record where he saw Neptune earlier, but had not previously attracted his attention….”

The problem is Galileo’s black dot from January 6 isn’t labeled. We know it was Neptune, but we cannot know what Galileo thought it was. And all the available evidence is that Galileo probably didn’t deduce the object’s true nature.

So, in other words, Neptune was officially discovered on September 23, 1846, by Urbain Le Verrier. Vive la France!
0

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

Read and share your comments on this article
Comment on this article
Want to leave a comment?
Only registered members of Astronomy.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes.

Login or Register now.
0 comments
ADVERTISEMENT
FREE EMAIL NEWSLETTER

Receive news, sky-event information, observing tips, and more from Astronomy's weekly email newsletter. View our Privacy Policy.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Apollo_RightRail
A chronicle of the first steps on the Moon, and what it took to get there.
Find us on Facebook